HB4346 AM MANCHIN 2-25 #1

    Delegate Manchin moves to amend the bill on page one, immediately following the enacting section, by striking out the remainder of the bill and inserting in lieu thereof the following:

“ARTICLE 5. AIR POLLUTION CONTROL.

§22-5-20. Regulating carbon dioxide emissions from existing fossil fuel-fired electric generating units.

    (a) The Department of Environmental Protection, in consultation with the Department of Environmental Protection Advisory Council, shall establish separate standards of performance for carbon dioxide emissions from existing coal-fired electric generating units in accordance with subsection (b) and from existing natural gas-fired electric generating units in accordance with subsection (c). The standards of performance developed and proposed under any state plan to comply with section 111 of the Clean Air Act should allow for greater flexibility and take into consideration the additional factors set forth in subsection (d) as a part of any state plan to achieve targeted reductions in greenhouse gas emissions which are equivalent or comparable to the goals and marks established by federal guidelines.

    (b) Standards of performance for existing coal-fired electric generating units. -- Except as provided under subsection (d), the standard of performance established for existing coal-fired electric generating units under subsection (a) shall be based upon:

    (1) The best system of emission reduction which, taking into account the cost of achieving the reduction and any nonair quality health and environmental impact and energy requirements, has been adequately demonstrated for coal-fired electric generating units that are subject to the standard of performance;

    (2) Reductions in emissions of carbon dioxide that can reasonably be achieved through measures undertaken at each coal-fired electric generating unit; and

    (3) Efficiency and other measures that can be undertaken at each coal-fired electric generating unit to reduce carbon dioxide emissions from the unit without switching from coal to other fuels, cofiring other fuels with coal, or limiting the utilization of the unit.

    (c) Standards of performance for existing natural gas-fired electric generating units. -- Except as provided in subsection (d), the standard of performance established for existing gas-fired electric generating units under subsection (a) shall be based upon:

    (1) The best system of emission reduction which, taking into account the cost of achieving the reduction and any nonair quality health and environmental impact and energy requirements, has been adequately demonstrated for natural gas-fired electric generating units that are subject to the standard of performance;

    (2) Reductions in emissions of carbon dioxide that can reasonably be achieved through measures at each natural gas-fired electric generating unit; and

    (3) Efficiency and other measures that can be undertaken at the unit to reduce carbon dioxide emissions from the unit without switching from natural gas to other lower-carbon fuels or limiting the utilization of the unit.

    (d) Flexibility in establishing standards of performance. -- In developing a flexible state plan to achieve targeted reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, the Department of Environmental Protection shall endeavor to establish an achievable standard of performance for any existing fossil fuel-fired electric generating unit, and examine whether less stringent performance standards or longer compliance schedules may be implemented or adopted for existing fossil fuel-fired electric generating units in comparison to the performance standards established for new, modified or reconstructed generating units, based on the following:

    (1) Consumer impacts, including any disproportionate impacts of energy price increases on lower income populations;

    (2) Non air quality health and environmental impacts;

    (3) Projected energy requirements;

    (4) Market-based considerations in achieving performance standards;

    (5) The costs of achieving emission reductions due to factors such as plant age, location, or basic process design;

    (6) Physical difficulties with or any apparent inability to feasibly implement certain emission reduction measures;

    (7) The absolute cost of applying the performance standard to the unit;

    (8) The expected remaining useful life of the unit;

    (9) The economic impacts of closing the unit, including expected job losses, if the unit is unable to comply with the performance standard;

    (10) Any other factors specific to the unit that make application of a modified or less stringent standard or a longer compliance schedule more reasonable; and

    (11) Whether other reductions in greenhouse gases could be potentially achieved by other measures, including but not limited to reduction of overall energy requirements or implementation of additional conservation measures, to meet targeted goals and objectives.

    (e) Implementing standards of performance. -- The Department of Environmental Protection may, to the extent permissible, establish and implement performance standards for existing fossil fuel fired electric generating unit through regulatory mechanisms that provide flexibility in complying with the standards, including the averaging of emissions, emissions trading, or other alternative implementation measures that are determined to further the interests of West Virginia and its citizens.

    (f) State plan requirement. -- The Department of Environmental Protection shall propose or submit to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency a state plan which includes achievable performance standards for existing sources, and a combination of additional measures designed to meet the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s guidelines, consistent with the considerations,

goals and parameters set forth in this section.”